Nairobi, Kenya — A proposed amendment to Kenya’s information and communications laws has sparked significant controversy by mandating that internet service providers monitor subscriber data consumption and assign unique meter numbers to customers. The Kenya Information and Communications (Amendment) Bill, 2025, sponsored by Member of Parliament Marianne Jebet Kitany, aims to ensure consumers are billed accurately for their internet usage. However, the legislative move has drawn sharp criticism from the Communications Authority of Kenya, telecommunications firms, and civil society organizations, who argue that the proposal lacks adequate safeguards for personal data and could negatively impact the sector’s growth.
The bill requires providers to track usage, convert it into readable details, and submit billing system information to the regulator annually. While the legislation does not explicitly mandate the recording of message content or website visits, critics question how identifiable usage records will be stored, accessed, and shared. Demas Kiprono of the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) Kenya argues that the collection of such data may not be proportionate to the stated goal of consumer protection, noting that existing regulatory powers are sufficient to handle billing complaints.
Privacy concerns are highlighted by recent legal precedents, such as the case of university student David Ooga Mokaya. After being acquitted on charges related to a social media post, Mokaya obtained a court order in February 2025 restraining parties from disclosing his personal data, including metadata and location records, without consent. This legal dispute illustrates the complex questions surrounding the collection and disclosure of telecommunications data in Kenya.
Beyond privacy, there are significant economic concerns. In a submission to parliament on November 3, the Communications Authority cautioned against compulsory metering, warning it could undermine affordability and digital inclusion for low-income households, students, and small businesses. Instead of a uniform billing model, the regulator recommended alternative measures such as usage alerts at 50, 80, and 100 percent capacity, free real-time dashboards, and independent audits of billing systems. Mugo Kibati, Chief Executive Officer of Telkom Kenya, told a parliamentary committee on November 10 that while mobile internet is already billed by volume, imposing a uniform framework for fixed broadband could increase compliance costs and deter investment. Kibati urged legislators to allow providers 18 months to adapt and to accept aggregated rather than individually identifiable data.
The debate occurs against a backdrop of increased public scrutiny over digital rights, following the 2024 protests against the Finance Bill. Legal experts, including Advocate Kelvin Kubai, argue that internet access is vital for civic participation and that new regulations must account for this. As the National Assembly’s Departmental Committee on Communication, Information and Innovation reviews the bill, lawmakers must balance the constitutional objective of protecting consumer economic interests with the risks to privacy and the sustainability of the telecommunications sector.
I worry this will make internet more expensive for us students. Existing regulators already have enough power to handle simple billing disputes.
Why not just fix the current billing issues instead of creating a massive surveillance tool? This feels disproportionate and risky for our privacy.