Internal communications from 2023, recently disclosed in California court filings, indicate that Meta considered a covert initiative to shape public opinion against sociologist Jonathan Haidt. The strategy, described as a “Whisper strategy,” aimed to persuade academics to critique Haidt ahead of the release of his influential book, The Anxious Generation, which argues that social media platforms negatively impact child development.
The revelation of this planned disinformation effort has largely backfired on the social media giant. Haidt, who has spent years publicizing his research on the harms of smartphones and social networking sites, is one of Meta’s most prominent critics. The disclosure of the internal proposal has created a rare point of consensus between Haidt and his intellectual detractors: both groups are now expressing significant anger toward Meta for its attempts to manipulate scholarly discourse.
While Haidt and his critics often disagree on the specific nuances of social media’s impact on mental health, the exposure of Meta’s strategy has unified them in opposition to the company. The incident highlights the growing legal and public scrutiny surrounding major tech platforms and their efforts to influence academic and public narratives.
Haidt might be right or wrong about social media, but Meta trying to rig the debate is indefensible. Full stop.
I am so tired of these companies playing games with the truth. They should just be fined for this interference.
Finally, a moment where even his critics agree with him. Meta has completely shot themselves in the foot here.
Did they actually hire the academics, or was it just a proposal? I need to know if money changed hands.
It makes sense why people are angry. Trying to sabotage a peer-reviewed scholar behind closed doors is a massive red flag.
The ‘Whisper strategy’ name is hilarious. It reminds me of old Cold War propaganda tactics, not modern corporate ethics.
I read Haidt’s book and thought it was good, but I was skeptical of his data. Meta’s behavior just disqualifies them from arguing.
This sounds like something out of a dystopian novel. Big Tech really thinks they can just buy off the scientific community.