A federal judge in Florida has ruled that US President Donald Trump’s $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC can move forward, following the broadcaster’s attempt to have the case dismissed. Judge Jeffrey Kuntz determined that the President’s allegations regarding a 2021 episode of Panorama were sufficient to sustain the lawsuit, although he noted that the final determination on the merits and damages will be addressed at a later stage.
In his ruling issued on Tuesday, Judge Kuntz dismissed a secondary claim in the lawsuit that alleged the BBC violated Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. The judge concluded that the documentary in question did not constitute commercial speech, which is a requirement under that specific state law.
The lawsuit centers on a 2021 broadcast in which the BBC edited segments of a speech delivered by Trump outside the US Capitol before the riot. The President argues that the broadcaster intentionally and deceptively manipulated the footage, while the BBC apologized for creating a mistaken impression that Trump made a direct call for violent action. The BBC has contended that the lawsuit should be dismissed because the program does not meet the legal criteria for defamation and was not available to US viewers.
President Trump celebrated the court’s decision on social media, describing it as a “huge victory.” In response, a spokesperson for the BBC stated that while the organization was surprised by the ruling, they respect the court’s authority and remain confident in their position, pledging to continue responding through proper legal channels.
Additionally, a separate court order requires Trump to answer deposition questions by December 11. The President had previously canceled a scheduled deposition, citing national importance, while a BBC lawyer noted that he was campaigning in Georgia on the day questions were originally set to be asked. Earlier this year, Trump’s legal team conceded there was no evidence the documentary was available in the US, and he subsequently dropped BBC Studios from the suit after the broadcaster argued it had no role in producing the specific episode.
Classic. They apologized years ago, so why is this still a huge legal battle in 2024?
He canceled his deposition for a campaign stop? How is that even allowed in a civil case?
Surprised the judge kept the defamation part alive. Thought the US availability claim would have killed it.
I remember watching that Panorama episode. The editing was messy, but did it really call for violence?
Ten billion? That is absolutely wild. Just seeing that number makes my head spin.