MP criticises Channel Islands’ new company ownership register plans as inadequate

MP criticises Channel Islands’ new company ownership register plans as inadequate

Plans to enhance transparency in the ownership of companies within Guernsey and Jersey have faced sharp criticism from a senior Westminster MP, who believes the measures are insufficient for tackling financial crime.

Sir Andrew Mitchell, a campaigner for rigorous scrutiny of corporate ownership structures, described the new proposals as not going “far enough.” His comments follow a joint commitment made by Guernsey, Jersey, and the Isle of Man in December 2023 to improve transparency and combat money laundering and terrorist financing.

The new framework would allow journalists, academics, and other applicants with a legitimate interest to access information regarding who controls or owns specific companies. However, Sir Mitchell argued that such access is often conditional and may create a “catch-22” for investigators who need data to prove wrongdoing in the first place.

He pointed out that Jersey’s consultation response expects applicants to demonstrate that “all reasonable alternative sources have been exhausted” before granting access. Sir Mitchell described this requirement as defeating the very purpose of the register. He also raised concerns that the system might exclude applicants from other jurisdictions, particularly those in the Global South, and questioned whether users would be required to pay fees to access the data.

“National security threats may remain entirely invisible to investigators,” Sir Mitchell warned, advocating that the register should eventually be fully public and free at the point of access.

Both island governments rejected these criticisms. A spokesperson for the Government of Jersey stated that the MP’s concerns “do not accurately reflect” the content of their consultation paper, emphasising that the policy is designed to maintain a “fair, proportionate, and effective transparency framework” while meeting international standards for countering financial crime.

Deputy Andrew Niles, of Guernsey’s Policy & Resources Committee, defended the proposals as based on a “tried and tested model adopted in the EU.” He highlighted a positive 2025 assessment of the island’s efforts and insisted that the framework balances access for legitimate investigators with the privacy and protection of vulnerable individuals.

5 responses to “MP criticises Channel Islands’ new company ownership register plans as inadequate”

  1. Feeding a few pennies to access data seems reasonable, but the ‘reasonable alternatives’ requirement is a huge red flag.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *