The U.S. Department of Justice has withdrawn its controversial legal challenge aimed at preventing the certification of Alaska’s U.S. Senate election results. In a filing to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday evening, the Justice Department declared the dispute “moot,” a move that effectively acknowledges Democratic Senator-elect Mary Peltola’s current lead in the electoral tally.
Following the Associated Press projection on Tuesday that Peltola will secure the victory, the department abandoned its earlier attempt to halt the counting process. This outcome marks the ninth Senate seat for the Democrats in the upcoming Congress. The litigation was initiated at the direction of President Donald Trump, who previously urged the Justice Department to file preemptive legal action if incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan lost the race.
The core of the lawsuit centered on allegations that a Republican candidate named Dan J. Sullivan ran a sham campaign to exploit the similarity of his name with the incumbent, thereby confusing voters and diverting votes away from Dan S. Sullivan. However, a federal judge in Alaska dismissed the suit on November 1, ruling that there was no viable method to investigate the claims regarding the submitted votes.
Stanley Woodward, the third-ranking official at the Justice Department, requested the appellate court to vacate the district judge’s dismissal order, not to revive the case, but to formally close the matter. “Instead, this Court should vacate the district court’s order dismissing this lawsuit, because the case has become moot,” Woodward wrote in the filing. The department added that it reluctantly acknowledged there was no longer any mechanism to determine whether ballots cast for the retired teacher Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent.
The withdrawal of the suit comes after days of President Trump publicly pressing for election officials to declare Senator Sullivan the winner by aggregating the votes of Dan J. Sullivan and another Republican candidate who was accused of being an unlawful spoiler recruited by Democrats.
The name similarity issue was confusing anyway. Glad Peltola can finally rest easy and head to Washington.
Wait, so they are just admitting the votes are uncountable now? That still feels pretty irregular to me.
Finally, some common sense. The lawsuit was always a stretch, so dropping it makes perfect sense to me.