Aberdeen liver surgery patient claims errors were made as review leaks surface

Aberdeen liver surgery patient claims errors were made as review leaks surface

Derek Appleton, a 60-year-old man from Stockport who was living in Orkney, has stated that he believes medical errors were made during a complex liver operation at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) that left him nearly dead.

After being diagnosed with stage four cancer, Appleton underwent surgery to remove 60% of his liver. The procedure resulted in him losing 11 litres of blood on the operating table—a volume significantly higher than the average human blood capacity of 4.5 to 5.5 litres—and he subsequently suffered cardiac arrest.

Appleton described the procedure as being described to him as “life-changing” before the operation, only for the outcome to be catastrophic. He noted that to stop severe bleeding, a surgeon had to manually pump his heart after his chest and rib cage were opened. “Technically I died, not one single person in theatre thought I was going to come out alive,” Appleton said. Four days post-operation, he was placed in an induced coma, and his partner was contacted from Spain to prepare for a funeral. Although Appleton has recovered, he maintains that he is “not the same person” as before and has not received a clear explanation for the complications.

Appleton’s account comes amid the publication of a leaked 2022 review by Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at ARI. The unpublished document examined 45 patients who died following liver and pancreatic surgery between 2015 and 2021, concluding that 19 of those deaths were avoidable consequences of surgical errors or interventions. The review indicated that mortality rates for major liver resections in the NHS Grampian area were significantly higher than national benchmarks, with a 12% death rate at 30 days and 18% at 90 days compared to an expected rate of 2.2%.

Following the leak, NHS Grampian has stated that a thorough investigation into these matters has already been conducted and that new evidence will be reviewed through clinical and legal processes. Police Scotland confirmed an ongoing investigation.

Karen Titchener, Scotland’s Patient Safety Commissioner, expressed concern that the full extent of the issues at NHS Grampian has not yet come to light. She described it as “totally unacceptable” that Health Secretary Angela Constance was previously unaware of the reports, despite Constance’s recent assurance that patients at ARI and Dr Gray’s Hospital were safe. Titchener is now seeking independent assurance that necessary changes are being implemented, noting that the avoidable deaths in emergency departments across Scotland last year number in the hundreds, indicating a broader systemic issue.

9 responses to “Aberdeen liver surgery patient claims errors were made as review leaks surface”

  1. NHS Grampian saying an investigation is ongoing feels like standard corporate deflection. We need independent oversight, not their word.

  2. The contrast between calling the surgery life-changing and the catastrophic outcome is truly chilling and dishonest.

  3. Why was this review unpublished for so long? Leaks like this usually expose deeper institutional failures that authorities try to hide.

  4. I’m glad Derek survived, but the trauma of that experience must be incredibly difficult. He needs proper legal representation immediately.

  5. Is the 12% mortality rate just for this one hospital or the whole NHS Grampian region? The context matters a lot here.

  6. Losing eleven liters of blood? That is impossible. It sounds like a complete breakdown of basic surgical protocol and accountability.

  7. The fact that his partner was contacted to prepare for a funeral while he was still alive is absolutely heartbreaking and unacceptable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *