Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has defended her recent remarks suggesting that because double amputees can run marathons, individuals with mental health conditions should seek employment rather than claim state benefits.
Badenoch made the comments while outlining the party’s plan to reduce welfare spending by £36 billion annually. Her suggestions drew sharp criticism from Prime Minister Andy Burnham, who described the wording as “crass and insensitive.” Paralympian Richard Whitehead, a double amputee marathon runner with four Olympic medals, also objected, accusing the Conservative leader of “weaponising” his personal sporting achievements in a political debate.
In an interview with the BBC’s Radio 4 Today programme, Badenoch maintained that her stance was based on common sense. “If people even with significant problems can work, then those who have ADHD and mild anxiety should go to work,” she stated. She rejected the idea that her comments were insensitive, asserting that she was simply speaking the truth and that if individuals are capable of working, society should encourage them to do so.
While acknowledging that she had used “extreme examples to illustrate things,” Badenoch argued that the ability of some people to overcome significant physical challenges implies that conditions like ADHD or anxiety are less severe. “I start from first principles: If you can work, you should work, and the Conservative Party is going to help you get a job,” she added.
The criticism follows a speech in which Badenoch cited examples of resilient individuals, including double amputees running marathons and people with autism leading major technology firms, to justify the proposed changes. Whitehead responded on social media, stating that disability should be evaluated based on the daily barriers families face rather than through isolated examples of individual achievement. He noted that the fact some amputees run marathons does not make disability support unnecessary.
As part of the Conservative proposal to overhaul sickness and disability benefits, the party intends to stop payments for “milder mental health issues and neurodiversity conditions such as anxiety, depression and ADHD,” as well as routine back and joint pain. The government claims these reforms will save £13.7 billion a year, with an additional £1 billion invested in health support to assist those no longer eligible for cash benefits.
We need more nuanced discussions on disability, not just soundbites about marathon runners.
The irony of weaponizing a Paralympian’s success for political cuts is hard to miss here.
Maybe she was just using a hyperbole to make a broader point about capability limits.
I worry about the people who will genuinely suffer under these new strict eligibility criteria.
It is weird how quickly political figures can dismiss mental health struggles with such extremes.
Thirteen billion dollars in savings is impressive, but what about the actual support for people?
Badenoch is right that everyone should try to work, but the delivery was tactless.
I am skeptical that this plan helps anyone. It just seems like an excuse to slash services.
Richard Whitehead makes a valid point. Individual athletic feats do not erase the daily struggles of disability.
Comparing anxiety to running a marathon without legs is genuinely shocking and completely misses the point.