US Explores Ukraine Land-for-NATO Deal Amid Expert Skepticism

US Explores Ukraine Land-for-NATO Deal Amid Expert Skepticism

United States officials have explored the possibility of Ukraine ceding parts of Donetsk province currently under its control in exchange for NATO membership or specific security guarantees. The proposal centers on the Donbas region, comprising Donetsk and Luhansk provinces, where Russia currently controls most of Luhansk and large portions of Donetsk, though Ukrainian forces continue to hold major cities such as Kramatorsk and Sloviansk.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated that no concrete proposal has been presented yet. He indicated that he would publicly address the matter once the US and NATO member states agree on a plan, noting that he cannot make such a decision unilaterally. Zelenskyy emphasized that any agreement would proceed without recognizing Russia’s occupation of these territories.

The US has suggested security guarantees similar to those found in Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, which call for consultations on imminent threats and collective defense against attacks, respectively. However, US officials have specified that they envision bilateral guarantees modeled after arrangements with Israel and certain Middle Eastern countries, rather than deploying troops on Ukrainian soil.

Experts interviewed by DW News have expressed skepticism regarding this approach. Oleksandr Kraiev of the Ukrainian Prism think tank compared the negotiation style to that of “real estate agents” and warned that the outcome could resemble the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, which promised security in exchange for nuclear disarmament but lacked enforceable defense commitments. Kraiev noted that at least half of NATO members have reservations about Ukraine’s accession.

The idea of using a referendum to decide on territorial cession is also criticized. Oleksandr Khara of the Centre for Defence Strategies argued that ceding territory would violate Ukraine’s constitution and set a dangerous precedent by suggesting borders can be redrawn through negotiation under pressure. A recent survey by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology found that 61% of respondents categorically reject withdrawing troops from Ukrainian-controlled parts of the Donbas, even in exchange for US and European security guarantees.

Alternative solutions have been proposed by analysts, including the creation of a “nuclear shield” with strategic protection from the US and tactical support from Europe. Sergiy Solodkyy of the New Europe research center suggested that Ukraine could join NATO within its internationally recognized borders with specific protocols limiting defense to territories under Kyiv’s control, similar to the historical case of West Germany. Solodkyy described the proposed land-for-security deal as a trap that risks recognizing Russian border claims.

2 responses to “US Explores Ukraine Land-for-NATO Deal Amid Expert Skepticism”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *