Steve Rosenberg, BBC Russia editor based in Shenzhen, asserts that the upcoming trilateral talks between Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump, and Xi Jinping represent a significant diplomatic victory for the Kremlin, regardless of the meeting’s final outcomes.
Nearly five years after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, which previously isolated the Russian leader on the international stage, Putin has secured a historic venue in Shenzhen. This event marks the first time the heads of state from China, Russia, and the United States will meet in a three-way format, allowing Putin to project an image of restored relevance in global politics.
The Russian president has already highlighted the futility of Western sanctions, stating at an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation business forum that attempts to isolate Russia have failed. While the Kremlin describes the trilateral meeting with Trump and Xi as the ‘showstopper’ of the event, this occurs against the backdrop of continued Russian military operations in Ukraine and the rejection of comprehensive ceasefire proposals.
European leaders and Ukraine express concern that the summit could lead to a diplomatic reshuffling similar to the 1945 Yalta Conference. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky warned that the meeting must not result in a ‘redistribution of influence’ regarding the conflict. Although President Trump has indicated that the war in Ukraine will be a central topic for discussion, the absence of Ukrainian and other European officials from the room is viewed with apprehension by Kyiv.
Meanwhile, Beijing has characterized the agenda more broadly, focusing on safeguarding world peace and strategic stability. Despite the enhanced diplomatic optics provided by the summit in Shenzhen, Rosenberg notes that Russia continues to face significant military challenges and recent setbacks, including damage to the Crimean bridge, indicating that diplomatic visibility does not equate to a military victory.
I hope this doesn’t turn into another Yalta-style deal where smaller nations get completely erased.
If sanctions failed to isolate him, hosting him at the APEC forum certainly changes the narrative.
Beijing is playing the long game again. They love seeing the West fracture while they sit back.
The Crimean bridge damage is real evidence. You cannot just host a summit and claim total victory.
Trump wants to talk about the war, but will he actually enforce any real consequences for Moscow?
Did anyone notice Ukraine is completely absent from these discussions? That should worry all of us quite a bit.
Shenzhen hosting this feels incredibly surreal. I can’t believe we are seeing three major powers meet face-to-face here.
Calling this a win ignores the ongoing war. Diplomatic optics do not stop the fighting on the ground.