Ed Miliband, the UK’s Foreign Secretary, has stated that he will not resign from his post if the government approves the development of the Rosebank oil field. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Mr. Miliband affirmed his commitment to ‘collective responsibility,’ a convention requiring cabinet ministers to publicly support government decisions even when they personally disagree with them.
This decision is particularly significant because Mr. Miliband had previously criticized the project during the Labour party’s time in opposition. In 2023, he described the scheme as a ‘colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism.’ Now a member of the executive branch, he said he would not ‘second guess’ the decision of his successor in the role of energy secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh, who is responsible for reviewing the quasi-judicial aspects of the approval process.
Mr. Miliband noted that he supported the recent green light given to the Jackdaw gas field, which saw gas begin flowing on Monday after years of legal uncertainty. While acknowledging the economic impacts of the Russia-Ukraine war and the Iran conflict on living costs, he argued that these events highlight the necessity of transitioning to ‘homegrown clean energy’ such as wind, solar, and nuclear power, rather than relying on fossil fuels for energy security.
The controversy over Rosebank has led to internal divisions within the Labour party. Reports indicate that at least 75 Labour MPs, including Catherine Fookes, MP for Monmouthshire, have signed a letter opposing the project, arguing that North Sea drilling would exacerbate climate change. Conversely, other Labour MPs, such as Steve Yemm, MP for Mansfield, support the project, viewing it as a test of whether the UK can balance North Sea investment with its climate obligations.
The Conservatives have criticized the Labour government for what they describe as inconsistent energy policy. Shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie argued that Labour’s inability to manage its own MPs, whom he said are ‘poised to rebel’ over Rosebank, undermines investor confidence and the industry. He stated, ‘One gas field does not make an energy strategy.’
Rosebank, located approximately 80 miles northwest of Shetland, is Britain’s largest untapped oil field. It is expected to produce up to 500 million barrels of oil over a 25-year period. A previous approval granted by the Conservative government in 2023 was ruled unlawful by the Court of Session in Edinburgh last year, placing the decision on the new Labour government. Environmental campaigners warn that approving Rosebank would hinder climate goals and produce more greenhouse gases than the Jackdaw gas field, while noting that international market prices mean increased supply is not guaranteed to lower domestic energy bills. The UK remains committed to reaching net zero carbon emissions by 2050 and limiting global warming to 1.5C.
Calling it a test of balancing investment with climate goals is pure politics. It is just greenwashing to appease investors.
I wonder if approving this will actually lower my bills or just enrich foreign owners? The market math seems sketchy.
Seventy-five Labour MPs signing that letter is a massive red flag. How can they claim unity when so many rebel?
It is fascinating to see him defend a project he previously called climate vandalism. That is the price of cabinet responsibility.