Five European Union member states are poised to announce the establishment of a migrant deportation center in Rwanda, a move aimed at strengthening removal efforts and curbing irregular migration across the bloc. Diplomatic sources indicate that Germany, Denmark, Austria, Greece, and the Netherlands will designate a ‘return hub’ located in Kigali, the capital of the landlocked east-central African nation.
The initiative aligns with a recent EU regulatory reform that permits the creation of such external facilities. Officials clarify that this scheme will apply exclusively to asylum seekers who have utilized all available legal avenues to remain in the EU. This approach differs significantly from the discontinued 2022 British proposal, which planned to send individuals to Rwanda for the initial processing of their claims. The UK plan was ultimately abandoned by the incoming Labour government in 2024 after facing persistent legal hurdles.
Rwanda confirmed in August that it had initiated preliminary talks with several European countries. The new hub is expected to operate initially as a pilot program, accommodating approximately 100 individuals, with each of the five participating nations potentially sending around 20 migrants, according to diplomatic sources speaking to the AFP news agency. The coalition reportedly aims to have the facility operational by 2027.
The International Organization for Migration (IOM) may play a supporting role in the project. An IOM spokesperson noted that the agency has extensive experience assisting migrants in transit and complex settings, and is currently in discussions with EU countries regarding the establishment of return hubs or similar mechanisms.
Critics have raised significant concerns regarding the selection of Rwanda. Clementine de Montjoye, senior Africa researcher at Human Rights Watch, expressed that Kigali’s human rights record is a major cause for alarm, citing a “well-established record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention, ill-treatment in detention” and support for armed rebels in the neighboring Democratic Republic of the Congo. De Montjoye argued that funding this deportation program would not only inflict suffering on the individuals involved but also provide financial and political leverage to a government accused of serious human rights violations both domestically and internationally.
Sending them to a country with such a terrible human rights record feels wrong, no matter the policy.
The legal distinction from the UK model is clever, but are these facilities truly ethical for vulnerable people?