Baroness Hilary Cass, the author of the independent review into gender identity services for young people, has stated that she does not support the current draft bill banning conversion practices due to fears of “serious unintended consequences.”
Speaking to a parliamentary committee overseeing the legislation, the Baroness highlighted that the bill’s wording could place medical professionals at risk of prosecution and cause distress for parents of children suffering from gender distress. Although she had previously welcomed the government’s move to legislate against such practices, she clarified that her prior support was for the general concept of a ban, not the specific details of the current draft.
Baroness Cass raised specific concerns about the threshold for “serious harm” in the bill, arguing it opens the door to vexatious complaints. She noted that therapists working with young, gender-distressed individuals could face legal action if their discussions of traumatic experiences—such as sexual abuse—are deemed distressing, even if the goal is therapeutic. Additionally, she cited examples where parents restricting a child’s financial access to items like hormones or binders might inadvertently fall within the scope of the legislation.
The government, which introduced the draft bill in June with the aim of protecting LGBT people in England and Wales, welcomed the evidence provided by the Baroness. A spokesperson stated that they are taking all comments seriously to ensure the ban is crafted correctly, while reiterating the commitment to ending the abuse associated with conversion practices. Baroness Cass, who described such practices as “abhorrent” in her 2024 report, urged the committee to refine the bill so it protects intended victims without entrapment of medical professionals or well-meaning families.
The government needs to fix the threshold for serious harm before this passes. It’s too broad currently.
Unintended consequences are real. If the wording is loose, we will see a flood of unnecessary complaints.
Surprised the Baroness changed her tune so quickly. She did support a ban earlier, right? Clarification needed.
Doctors should have legal protections when doing their job. This bill feels like it targets therapy rather than abuse.
I’m worried about parents getting sued for not funding gender-affirming care. The definition of harm is way too vague.