The selection process for the next United Nations Secretary-General has entered a decisive phase, with the UN Security Council holding multiple straw polls to identify a successor to incumbent Antonio Guterres. The current process, characterized by secret votes and the threat of vetoes from the five permanent members, aims to secure a consensus by December 31, when Guterres’ term concludes.
Eight candidates are currently in the race, including Rebeca Grynspan of Costa Rica, head of the UN Conference on Trade and Development, and Rafael Grossi of Argentina, the chief of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Other contenders include Lana Nusseibeh of the United Arab Emirates, Feridun Hadi Sinirlioglu of Turkey, and representatives from Ecuador, Guyana, and Uganda. Grynspan is noted for her role in brokering the 2022 Black Sea Grain Initiative, while Grossi has overseen nuclear non-proliferation efforts but faced criticism regarding his reporting on Iran.
The Security Council, comprising the five permanent members—China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom, and the United States—and ten elected non-permanent members, evaluates candidates through informal anonymous polls. Candidates must secure at least nine “encourage” votes and avoid a veto from any of the permanent members to be formally recommended to the UN General Assembly. According to Article 97 of the UN Charter, the General Assembly provides final approval, though it has historically not rejected a candidate endorsed by the Security Council.
Recent voting trends show Rebeca Grynspan leading in the eighth straw poll with 12 encourage votes and three discourage votes. Rafael Grossi follows with nine encourage votes, four discourage votes, and two no-opinion votes. The exact breakdown of votes among the permanent members remains undisclosed, a practice that critics argue is outdated and lacking in transparency. Jane Kinninmont, CEO of the United Nations Association UK, noted that while the process has become somewhat more open due to civil society pressure, the Security Council continues to guard its secrecy, partly to avoid political resentment from nations whose preferred candidates are not appointed.
If no candidate is selected by the December 31 deadline, the UN Charter provides no explicit contingency plan. Options may include recommending a candidate for a shorter term or appointing a senior official to oversee operations in the interim. Antonio Guterres has indicated that he expects to return to Portugal on January 1, but the outcome of the selection process remains uncertain as negotiations continue among the permanent members.
Does it even matter if the General Assembly approves them? They never reject the Security Council’s pick.
Twelve encourage votes is a good lead, but one veto from Russia or China kills it instantly.
If Guterres really just leaves on the 1st with no replacement, that’s going to look bad for everyone.
Secret ballots and vetoes are just power plays disguised as procedure. I wish we had more transparency.
Interesting that the UAE has a candidate this time. Usually, the race feels a bit more predictable than this.
Grossi has been under a lot of pressure from that Iran reporting controversy. That might hurt him here.
What actually happens if nobody is picked by New Year’s? Does the UN just stop functioning overnight?
Still can’t believe we don’t know who voted for whom. This process feels like a shadowy backroom deal.
I hope Grynspan gets the job. Her work on the grain deal was genuinely impressive and necessary.