A large crowd of demonstrators gathered in Edinburgh on Saturday to protest the construction of major artificial intelligence data centres. The group marched down the Royal Mile towards the Scottish Parliament building, carrying placards and slogans that expressed concern over the environmental impact and local consequences of the projects.
The rally is part of a broader movement across Europe questioning the sustainability of data infrastructure. In Scotland, the debate has intensified over proposals for massive facilities in areas such as Cockenzie, East Lothian, and Larbert, Falkirk. Campaigners like Kim Cairns, who opposes a planned centre near Chapelcross, argued that such sites would transform green landscapes into industrial zones, increasing noise, air pollution, and energy consumption without providing clear benefits to local residents.
Protesters wore costumes and held signs with messages such as “hands off our habitat” and “we can’t drink data.” While some experts view AI as a transformative technology with risks of rapid development, the primary concern in Scotland remains the physical scale of the data centres. The current largest facility in the country, located in Airdrie, has a capacity of 12 megawatts, whereas a proposed project in Dumfries and Galloway aims for 1,000 megawatts, which would make it one of the largest in the world.
Political figures have noted that data centres are often compared to the whisky industry in terms of economic potential, with Innovation Minister Alyn Smith recently describing them as “the whisky bonds of the AI sector.” However, environmental groups, including the Scottish Greens and Friends of the Earth, are calling for a pause on large-scale projects to protect climate targets and prevent a surge in energy bills. Kim Pratt of Friends of the Earth emphasized that the national-level impacts of these energy-hungry developments require public input.
The Scottish government stated it is developing a strategy to ensure data centres deliver public benefit and will publish new planning guidance by the end of the year. This includes mandatory Environmental Impact Assessments for any new data centre with a power capacity exceeding 50 megawatts.
If the energy bills skyrocket because of this, I won’t care where the data lives.
My kids think it’s funny. We can’t drink data is actually quite catchy and memorable.
Great to see a pause being called for. Rushing in without local consent is reckless.
Calling it the whisky of AI is a stretch. Whisky has export value; electricity is a utility.
I live near East Lothian. The noise from the current facilities is already getting worse at night.
The environmental impact assessments are a start, but who enforces them once the concrete is poured?
We need those jobs. Airdrie’s hub is a success, let’s not scare off investors with panic.
Is it just us or does this feel like the same old green vs. growth argument all over again?
Love the costumes! Data doesn’t pollute, but the cooling systems definitely do. Good protest.
1000 megawatts is insane. That’s practically a small power plant just cooling servers in Dumfries.