International study: BMI alone insufficient for accurate obesity diagnosis

International study: BMI alone insufficient for accurate obesity diagnosis

A major international study published in Nature indicates that relying solely on Body Mass Index (BMI) can lead to missed or incorrect obesity diagnoses. Researchers analyzed health data from 844,108 adults across China, the UK, the US, and Spain to evaluate current diagnostic methods against a proposed new framework.

The findings suggest that current standard practices fail to differentiate between individuals who already suffer from health issues caused by excess body fat and those who are at increased risk but still have normal organ function. The study supports a framework proposed in January 2025 by a commission in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, which categorizes obesity into two distinct types: clinical obesity, where excess fat impairs organ function or daily activities, and preclinical obesity, where excess fat raises health risks without yet affecting bodily function.

According to the research, using BMI alone resulted in classification errors, with up to 8.6% of participants having obesity-level body fat that was missed, and up to 3.1% being incorrectly classified as having obesity. The study found that incorporating waist circumference and waist-to-height ratio alongside BMI significantly reduced these errors. Clinical obesity was identified in between 23% and 31% of all obesity cases, with a population prevalence ranging from 5.6% to 10.9%.

Professor Francesco Rubino, senior author of the study and chair of Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery at King’s College London, emphasized that patients with obesity deserve care tailored to their specific needs. “People with obesity, like everyone else, deserve care matched to their needs: no less, and no more,” Rubino stated. He noted that BMI cannot determine whether a person is currently ill or merely at risk, leaving them vulnerable to either undertreatment or overtreatment.

The data showed that clinical obesity is associated with a substantially higher risk of death compared to preclinical obesity. Furthermore, most individuals classified as having preclinical obesity at the start of the study—between 77% and 91% across the different cohorts—did not progress to clinical obesity over a ten-year period. Professor An Pan, first author of the study from Huazhong University of Science and Technology in Wuhan, China, argued that the consistent differences in prognosis across various countries and ethnic groups support the global adoption of this new framework to improve obesity care and policy.

6 responses to “International study: BMI alone insufficient for accurate obesity diagnosis”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *