Labour members of Parliament have urged the UK government to reject the Rosebank oil and gas project, stating that it is incompatible with the nation’s climate commitments. The debate emerged as senior Labour figures increasingly signal that production in the field, located 80 miles northwest of Shetland, will be approved. The decision will be formally announced by Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, who has emphasized that the affordability of energy bills is her primary objective.
Signs of internal division within the party became apparent during a Westminster Hall debate on Wednesday, where approximately a dozen Labour MPs expressed their opposition. Additionally, more than 60 out of the roughly 400 Labour MPs have indicated their support for a letter to Prime Minister Andy Burnham, which has not yet been sent. One signatory argued that approving Rosebank would not create new jobs, would provide minimal financial benefit to the Treasury, and would harm the climate.
Abtisam Mohamed, the Labour MP for Sheffield Central, stated that Rosebank fails to benefit taxpayers, who will bear most of the development costs. She argued that the project would not strengthen energy security, as most of the oil would be sold on international markets, nor would it reduce energy bills, leaving constituents exposed to volatile fossil fuel prices. Richard Burgon, a former frontbencher, added that the project is dangerous to the UK’s goal of reaching net zero by 2050.
The legal status of the project was complicated after the Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled last year that previous approvals granted by the Conservative government in 2022 and 2023 were unlawful. This ruling placed the final decision on the current Labour government, which had pledged in its 2024 manifesto not to issue new licences for exploring new fields. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch utilized the issue to highlight Labour’s internal divisions during Prime Minister’s Questions.
While many MPs opposed the project, some highlighted the need for energy security and jobs in coastal communities. Jonathan Brash, the Labour MP for Hartlepool, stressed the benefits of the project for British jobs. Energy minister Michael Shanks described the government’s approach as pragmatic, noting that it would not be a ‘turn off the taps government’ nor a ‘drill every last drop government,’ while maintaining that decisions must remain compatible with climate obligations.
Shetland voters deserve a real say instead of Westminster politicians dictating terms from London offices.
It is ironic that Labour opposes its own flagship project while trying to fix the cost of living crisis.