A Baird Securities analyst has downgraded Nvidia’s stock rating to neutral, warning that the chipmaker faces intensifying scrutiny from both regulatory bodies and markets. Tristan Gerra, the analyst at Baird, stated that a convergence of uncertainties—including potential U.S. government investigations and questions regarding the future of CEO Jensen Huang—has led to this cautionary move.
The downgrade follows recent reports that Huang admitted to an extramarital relationship with a woman whom U.S. authorities reportedly suspect of acting as an intelligence asset for China. Gerra compared the situation to the myth of Icarus, suggesting that Huang’s ambitions and personal conduct may have led the company into precarious territory. The analyst highlighted an upcoming in-person briefing with Congress and the possibility of new charges or leadership instability as key risk factors.
In a note to clients, Gerra outlined two primary scenarios that could impact Nvidia’s financials. First, the U.S. government could impose new export bans on the company’s H200 chips, potentially resulting in a $5 billion write-down on Nvidia’s books. This would mirror a similar write-down that occurred earlier in the year when the administration restricted the sale of less advanced chips to China. Gerra noted that low-level shipments of these chips are currently moving into Asian warehouses, awaiting Chinese buyers.
Second, new export controls might target loopholes that currently allow Nvidia’s chips to enter data centers in Southeast Asia. Specifically, the analyst pointed to Megaspeed, a Singapore-based cloud provider where the alleged intelligence asset worked as an executive, suggesting that the U.S. Department of Justice could take action against the firm. Such actions could trigger preemptive measures by other regional data-center operators with exposure to Chinese demand, which has historically exceeded Wall Street estimates.
While demand from U.S. cloud providers currently exceeds supply, allowing Nvidia to absorb some weakness in the region through next year, Gerra warned that if China-related demand vanishes or Southeast Asian shipments are restricted, the revenue impact could be concentrated in specific quarters. He also noted that estimates for data-center buildouts in 2027 are being delayed due to component supply constraints, potentially slowing the annual growth rate of AI spending by hyperscalers to 40% or less.
Given that Nvidia’s valuation already factors in some concerns regarding data-center development, Gerra lowered his price target from $500 to $200. The stock was trading at $175.85 on Wednesday, having surged more than 4% that day after suffering its worst five-day performance since September 2022 by Tuesday’s close. The sharp decline in the share price also prompted Morgan Stanley analyst Joseph Moore to remove Nvidia from his top picks list, citing the bank’s stop-loss policy, although he maintained his overweight rating on the stock due to the critical importance of Huang’s leadership for the company’s strategy.
Does the Icarus comparison mean they expect leadership instability soon, or is it just a dramatic metaphor for risk?
I am genuinely surprised that Morgan Stanley kept their overweight rating despite removing it from their top picks.
Dropping the price target to $200 while the stock is already at $175 is painfully accurate and realistic.