Welsh First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth has described himself as “pretty gobsmacked” following a formal rejection by Prime Minister Andy Burnham of long-standing requests to transfer specific powers from Westminster to Cardiff Bay.
In a letter reviewed by BBC Wales, Prime Minister Burnham stated he was “not persuaded” by the arguments to devolve responsibilities regarding policing, the justice system, the Crown Estate, and rail infrastructure to the Welsh Government. The decision contradicts earlier indications of positive engagement between the two leaders during a recent meeting in Glasgow.
Speaking on BBC Radio Wales, the First Minister criticized the decision as evidence that Westminster was disregarding the will of the Welsh people. “This is about Westminster saying, we decide, it doesn’t matter what the people of Wales think,” ap Iorwerth said. He noted that while there had been significant engagement within UK government departments, the final decision lacked meaningful consultation with Wales.
Stephen Kinnock, the Secretary of State for Wales, defended the Prime Minister’s position, arguing that devolving these powers would lead to “destabilisation and fragmentation and disintegration.” Kinnock highlighted that the UK government had offered an alternative package focusing on fiscal powers, employment support, and regional empowerment to bring growth closer to local communities.
Burnham’s letter outlined specific reasons for retaining central control. On policing, he argued that an integrated England and Wales system is essential for interoperability and allows Welsh forces to access national and specialist capabilities. Regarding justice, he maintained that the current devolution settlement allows Wales to benefit from the shared resources and expertise of a unified system.
The rejection also covers the Crown Estate, which includes the seabed off the Welsh coast and generates revenue for the UK Treasury. Both the previous Welsh Labour government and the current Plaid Cymru administration had advocated for its devolution. Burnham contended that the current model best maximizes economic and social benefits for Wales and refused to explore transferring its management. On rail infrastructure, the Prime Minister stated that delivery is best handled by the new Great British Railways in collaboration with Transport for Wales, warning that full devolution would fragment the integrated cross-border network.
A spokesperson for the First Minister accused Burnham of “turning his back on devolution,” suggesting that the Prime Minister’s commitment to decentralizing power applied only to English regions. “His warm words on devolution are now ringing hollow… there is no longer any doubt that when he talks of driving power out of Whitehall, he only means to the regions of England,” the spokesperson said.
The decision also places Burnham at odds with Ken Skates, the leader of Welsh Labour, who recently reiterated at a party conference that policing and the Crown Estate should be devolved.
Frankly, mixing up Welsh and English policing sounds like a recipe for total administrative disaster. Glad they held firm on this one.
Another broken promise. Cardiff is tired of being treated like a footnote while the English regions get the attention.