A significant review into the lives of young people not in education, employment, or training (Neets) is expected to propose sweeping changes to the UK’s welfare and employment systems. The report, led by former Labour MP Alan Milburn, suggests a dramatic rebalancing of public spending to prioritize job creation and training over direct financial support for under-25s.
Currently, nearly one million people under the age of 25 in the UK fall into the Neet category. Milburn highlights that spending on benefits for this demographic is approximately 25 times higher than the amount spent on helping them find work. The proposal aims to shift this ratio to two-to-one, meaning that while some young people may face reduced or cut benefits, there will be a substantial increase in state-funded education, training, and subsidized employment opportunities.
A key component of the review is a proposed new legal ‘opportunity guarantee,’ which would mandate that authorities provide young people with a job, apprenticeship, training place, or necessary health treatment. This legal duty is intended to ensure permanent structural change rather than temporary schemes that can be easily reversed by subsequent governments. The recommendations apply across the United Kingdom, though specific implementations in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland will be detailed in future legislation.
The proposal comes at a time when the issue of youth unemployment is escalating; recent research indicates that without intervention, the number of Neets could reach 1.26 million by 2031. The annual cost of the issue is estimated at £22 billion. While Milburn acknowledges that some young people are capable of working but do not, he emphasizes that the vast majority wish to be employed and that the system needs to support them.
Political reactions are mixed. The Conservative and Reform parties have criticized the plan as slow, arguing that immediate cuts to the welfare bill are necessary, with Reform calling the review ‘pointless’ without swift action. Within the Labour Party, the review tests Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s willingness to engage in difficult welfare debates. Welfare Secretary Pat McFadden has spent considerable time briefing MPs on the proposals. Although concerns remain from left-wing parties such as the Greens and SNP regarding benefit cuts, government sources indicate that Prime Minister Burnham and Chancellor Rishi Sunak are aware of the report’s contents and that the political groundwork for implementation has been laid.
The twenty-five to one spending ratio shocked me. It really does seem like we are paying people to stay out of work.
Is this just political theater? We keep promising structural change, but usually, the next government just reverses it all.
Finally, someone is addressing the massive gap between spending on benefits versus actual support for employment.
Cutting benefits before job training is risky. Many young people face mental health barriers first, not just a lack of options.