{"id":1861,"date":"2026-11-12T15:50:50","date_gmt":"2026-11-12T15:50:50","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/2026\/11\/12\/the-toxic-vengeance-of-capital-punishment\/"},"modified":"2026-11-12T15:50:50","modified_gmt":"2026-11-12T15:50:50","slug":"the-toxic-vengeance-of-capital-punishment","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/2026\/11\/12\/the-toxic-vengeance-of-capital-punishment\/","title":{"rendered":"The Toxic Vengeance of Capital Punishment"},"content":{"rendered":"<section>\n<figure><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/static.time.com\/v3\/assets\/bltea6093859af6183b\/bltf306a0f322679aa4\/6af3f8c363734cb536c9255d\/Capital-Punishment.jpg?branch=production\" \/><figcaption> \u2014Max Zolotukhin\u2014Getty Images<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<\/section>\n<section>\n<p>Two radical ideas have been introduced into human thought, wrote the novelist and humorist Kurt Vonnegut. One was that \u201cenergy and matter are pretty much the same sort of stuff.\u201d That was Einstein. The other was that \u201crevenge is a bad idea.\u201d That was Jesus. We are so wired for vengeance, so trained to retaliate, mused Vonnegut, Jesus must be classed among the revolutionaries.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Vonnegut was no Christian, preferring to describe himself as a \u201cChrist-worshipping agnostic,\u201d but he dreamed of a world in which the long \u201cchain of death and destruction\u201d is broken. That is why he opposed the death penalty and one of the reasons he despaired of America. <\/p>\n<p>News that the execution of former Army psychiatrist <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/archive\/6915489\/fort-hood-were-hasans-warning-signs-ignored\/\">Nidal Hasan<\/a>, who murdered 13 U.S. soldiers in 2009, will <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/article\/2026\/10\/15\/trump-cancels-livestream-of-fort-hood-firing-squad-execution-amid-bipartisan-pushback\/\">not be livestreamed<\/a> in December has been well received, but <a href=\"https:\/\/www.washingtonpost.com\/national-security\/2026\/10\/15\/8-10-americans-oppose-live-streaming-execution-fort-hood-shooter-poll-shows\/\">reports<\/a> that a narrow majority of Americans approve of both the sentence and the method of <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/article\/2026\/10\/10\/firing-squad-execution-lethal-injection-christa-pike-fort-hood-shooter\/\">death-by-firing-squad<\/a> have excited little comment.<\/p>\n<p>Coming days after the botched execution of <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/article\/2026\/10\/02\/christa-pike-botched-execution-lethal-injection-tennessee-pentobarbital\/\">Christa Pike<\/a> in Tennessee, for a crime committed when she was a teenager, it is reasonable to ask: Why do we still execute people? <\/p>\n<p>Pope Leo has <a href=\"https:\/\/www.vaticannews.va\/en\/pope\/news\/2026-10\/pope-leo-xiv-tweet-death-penalty-inadmissible-dignity-person.html\">protested<\/a> the cruelty of a practice that denies \u201cthe possibility of redemption,\u201d but this is a political as well as a religious question. A culture of vengeance tears at the fabric of democracy.<\/p>\n<p>About 20 years ago, the legal scholar Terry Aladjem staged a debate on the death penalty for an undergraduate class at the University of Massachusetts in Boston. Expecting to have to work hard to convince students of its merits, Aladjem was shocked to discover that nearly all of them were in favor of capital punishment. The \u201cclass erupted,\u201d he recalled. \u201cThose who supported the death penalty vastly outnumbered their opponents. America was not what I thought it was.\u201d\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Aladjem went on to write a <a href=\"https:\/\/terryaladjem.scholars.harvard.edu\/publications\/culture-vengeance-and-fate-american-democracy\">book<\/a> about vengeance and how our appetite for violent punishment throws us back into a state of nature, fanning the dangerous passions that are supposed to be cooled and contained by the social contract.<\/p>\n<p>Vengeance was becoming the air we breathe, he observed. Talk shows, television justice, and politics seemed to be concerned with little else. Where liberal thought had banished the criterion of revenge from all considerations of justice, a politics of purity had brought it back. The result was \u201csomething absolutist, something profoundly undemocratic,\u201d wrote Aladjem. The president who wants to hunt down terrorists, \u201c<a href=\"https:\/\/www.voanews.com\/a\/a-13-a-2001-09-17-37-bush-66422492\/550110.html\">dead or alive<\/a>,\u201d and the angry talk show host \u201cwho entertains the views of others only to reinforce his own\u201d were peas in a pod. For Aladjem, the death penalty is at once deeply problematic on its own and a symptom of a wider malaise. He fears that the glee we might feel in the death of a \u201cbad person\u201d will come for us in the end.<\/p>\n<p>J. William Fulbright, the Senator for Arkansas and a longtime critic of the Vietnam War, made the same point in an <a href=\"https:\/\/digitalcollections.uark.edu\/digital\/collection\/Fulbright\/id\/630\/rec\/46\">essay<\/a> on \u201cThe American Character\u201d after the assassination of John F. Kennedy. Fulbright was appalled by the widespread expressions of sympathy for Jack Ruby, the man who shot Kennedy\u2019s alleged assassin live on television, thus depriving Lee Harvey Oswald of one of the basic rights of a civilized society: \u201cthe right to a fair trial under established procedures of law.\u201d This hunger for vengeance could not be dismissed as a normal feature of a healthy society. It spoke to an intolerance and bloodlust that was one part Salem, hanging witches on the strength of gossip, and one part frontier, hanging horse-thieves from trees. It was the Puritan spirit, immortalized in Arthur Miller\u2019s play <em>The Crucible, <\/em>that most troubled Fulbright.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cAlthough no Western nation has completely dispelled the absolutist spirit of the crusades and the religious wars, some have been more successful than others,\u201d he noted. The core of the democratic idea, going back to the critique of the divine right of kings, was \u201cthe element of doubt as to the ability of any man or any movement to perceive ultimate truth.\u201d But \u201cthe Puritan way of thinking\u201d injected an absolutist strand into American thought: a ferocious moralism eager to send sinners to hell. Fulbright\u2019s essay recalls much of what the founders wrote about the danger of regression to a psychology of vengeance, and the notion that tyranny exists wherever violence is praised.<\/p>\n<p>Raised on an 18th-century version of the Puritanism that distressed Fulbright, Benjamin Rush had an epiphany one day in 1787, when he chatted with a group of convicts cleaning the streets in Philadelphia. With their shaven heads and degrading uniforms, the men made a sorry spectacle as they begged him for a penny. Offering them a draught of beer instead, Rush was stunned by their humor and humanity as he listened to their stories. The strange thought began to dawn that criminals were humans, after all, and that no heart is \u201cwholly corrupted.\u201d To terminate such a life, or confine it to perpetual misery, was a crime against human nature, Rush <a href=\"https:\/\/press-pubs.uchicago.edu\/founders\/documents\/amendVIIIs16.html\">wrote<\/a>. America had won its independence from Britain, but true freedom\u2014freedom from cruelty and arbitrary violence\u2014was still distant, as long as Americans persisted in brutal punishments.<\/p>\n<p>To shed blood with little or no emotion, to treat a criminal like a sheep or a dog, was to demonstrate how little we have understood about liberty as a principle of life and republicanism as its protection. \u201cAn execution in a republic,\u201d he argued, \u201cis like a human sacrifice in religion.\u201d It was a return to a world that should have been left behind.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Rush was not alone. Integral to early American patriotism was the notion of a rational people, liberated from the \u201cbloody code\u201d of medieval law. A critical influence on Rush, Jefferson, and several of their contemporaries was the Italian philosopher Cesare Beccaria, whose <a href=\"https:\/\/oll.libertyfund.org\/titles\/voltaire-an-essay-on-crimes-and-punishments\"><em>Essay on Crimes and Punishments<\/em><\/a><em> <\/em>codified this notion of the death penalty as sanctified barbarism. It had taken centuries for societies to evolve from blood feuds and trial by combat to a system of tangible laws, in which the state serves as \u201cthe cool moderator of the passions of individuals.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>When the state takes up the sword of vengeance, Beccaria suggests, it forgets its very purpose in life. It falls into the absurdity of trying to prevent murder by committing murder itself. No one could deny that malice and cruelty stalk the gallows. The solemnities of the ritual cannot hide the fact that we are trying to erase a terrible evil with more of the same. And no wonder it fails, observed the Italian. The effect is to cheapen human life and to breed contempt for the law\u2014because it\u2019s hard to love a government that acts in the spirit of \u201cthe assassin.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>This was the idea that inspired Jefferson, as he set about reforming Virginia\u2019s penal code, confining capital punishment to murder and treason, and drastically reducing the number of physical punishments on the books. \u201cLet mercy be the character of the law-giver,\u201d he <a href=\"https:\/\/press-pubs.uchicago.edu\/founders\/documents\/amendVIIIs9.html\">wrote<\/a>. But let the law be as certain as gravity. Jefferson denied that in disputing \u201cthe sanguinary hue of our penal laws\u201d he was being soft on crime or na\u00efvely optimistic about human nature. For laws to be effective, they had to be reasonable, proportionate, and mild. One of his models was William Penn, who showed that the \u201cprinciples\u00a0of peace,\u00a0of reason and right\u201d can hold their own in the realm of government. Although it\u2019s unfortunate that he did not practice what he <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/article\/2026\/07\/03\/healing-america-means-rethinking-patriotism\/\">preached<\/a>, Jefferson\u2019s remarks on the corrosive effects of slavery reflected his notion that violence is a contagion and the law must limit its spread. \u201c[F]or man is an imitative animal,\u201d he <a href=\"https:\/\/encyclopediavirginia.org\/primary-documents\/query-xviii-an-excerpt-from-notes-on-the-state-of-virginia-by-thomas-jefferson-1784\/\">wrote<\/a>, and imitation is the seed of all education. When the child sees the parent lashing out, he \u201ccatches the\u00a0lineaments of wrath.\u201d Thus \u201cnursed\u201d and trained in tyranny, a tyrant is what he becomes.<\/p>\n<p>Advocates of the death penalty speak of justice, closure, and peace for the victims. But by Jefferson\u2019s lights, a public execution is an education in brutality and a reopening of wounds. The legendary defense lawyer Clarence Darrow <a href=\"https:\/\/chicago.suntimes.com\/2022\/4\/22\/23032424\/clarence-darrow-leopold-loeb-speech-closing-arguments\">argued<\/a> similarly that to punish murder with death is to \u201cmake less serious\u201d the original offense. It is to baptize violence as the way of the world, and to say that what goes around comes around.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Like Vonnegut, Darrow saw the death penalty as institutionalized vengeance, and he pleaded for an attitude of \u201cmercy\u201d to break the spell. \u201cIf our state is not kinder, more human, more considerate, more intelligent than the mad act of these two sick boys,\u201d he said, as he attempted to spare two teenage killers a sentence of death in 1924, \u201cthen I\u2019m sorry that I\u2019ve lived so long.\u201d But \u201cI know the future is on my side.\u201d\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Yet Darrow, believed to be the most brilliant and hard-headed attorney of his time, would be dismissed as a snowflake in ours. His language of clemency and kindness would likely be laughed at in an age when a Marine Corps veteran can <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/6277268\/jordan-neely-subway-death-homicide\/\">kill<\/a> a homeless passenger on the New York subway and walk free of all charges\u2014and even be lauded as a model of civic virtue.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>We all share the disease. President Bill Clinton\u2019s decision to interrupt his presidential campaign to deny clemency for a brain-damaged black man on death row, in 1992, captures the true story of the past 30 years: convergence. \u201cThe real Bill Clinton is not for capital punishment,\u201d <a href=\"https:\/\/georgetowner.com\/articles\/2019\/08\/07\/conversations-with-abner-mikva\/\">said<\/a> Illinois congressman Abner Mikva. He just thought it was \u201ca political necessity.\u201d Mikva saw the same dynamic playing out with handguns, lamenting a shift, in his lifetime, from serious talk of prohibition to the modern politician\u2019s terror of uttering a word against the deadly weapons.<\/p>\n<p>What stems the tide? While Secretary of State Marco Rubio scolds <a href=\"https:\/\/time.com\/article\/2026\/10\/29\/how-europe-is-defying-trump-by-rallying-around-the-icc\/\">Europe<\/a> for building \u201cdownwards\u201d and sacrificing the greatness of the Western tradition \u201c<a href=\"https:\/\/www.state.gov\/releases\/office-of-the-spokesman\/2026\/10\/secretary-of-state-marco-rubio-remarks\">to the average, the ordinary, the mediocre<\/a>,\u201d it is worth noting that every European nation except Belarus has abolished capital punishment, and that the nations with whom America shares the practice are those we have been taught to despise for their \u201c<a href=\"https:\/\/www.state.gov\/releases\/office-of-the-spokesman\/2026\/10\/secretary-of-state-marco-rubio-remarks\">cult of death<\/a>.\u201d We sit behind China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen among the countries with the <a href=\"https:\/\/www.amnesty.org\/en\/latest\/news\/2026\/05\/death-penalty-in-2025-facts-and-figures\/\">highest number<\/a> of executions per annum.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>My hope is that more states will follow California\u2019s lead in declaring state-sanctioned killing incompatible with \u201cjustice and human decency,\u201d as Governor Gavin Newsom wrote last week, when he <a href=\"https:\/\/www.gov.ca.gov\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/11\/2026-11-5-26-GGN-Open-Letter-FINAL.pdf\">commuted<\/a> the sentences of the state\u2019s 548 death row inmates. Although some of the relatives of the victims expressed their fury at Newsom\u2019s decision, one welcomed it in terms that would have pleased Benjamin Rush.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cWe used to think that having a vengeful death penalty sentence is going to be what gave us justice,\u201d Jess Nichol, stepsister of Polly Klass, who was murdered in 1993, <a href=\"https:\/\/www.nytimes.com\/2026\/11\/05\/us\/california-death-row-newsom-commutation.html\">told<\/a> <em>The New York Times<\/em>. \u201cWe\u2019ve discovered that it doesn\u2019t.\u201d\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Having at first thought that the killer deserved death, Ms. Nichol came to believe that healing required a degree of mercy. \u201cI want to live in a world where I am well, and not haunted by the hungry ghost of vengeance,\u201d she said.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>This, I would argue, has to be the future.<\/p>\n<\/section>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>\u2014Max Zolotukhin\u2014Getty Images Two radical ideas have been introduced into human thought, wrote the novelist and humorist Kurt Vonnegut. One was that&hellip;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":1862,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[1],"tags":[113],"class_list":["post-1861","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-uncategorized","tag-magazine"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1861","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=1861"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1861\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/1862"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=1861"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=1861"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/yowao.xyz\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=1861"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}