The U.S. House of Representatives has effectively stalled an attempt to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, surprising observers who anticipated a stronger Democratic push against President Donald Trump’s administration.
The procedural vote, taken on Tuesday, resulted in a 211-204 decision to refer the articles of impeachment back to the House Judiciary Committee. This move kills the immediate drive for impeachment for the current congressional term, which concludes in eight weeks when a new Democratic-controlled Congress takes office on January 3.
The articles were initially introduced by Republican Congressman Thomas Massie, who supported the measure despite his party’s alignment with the White House. However, the effort was primarily championed by Democrats, who accused Hegseth of abuses of power and conducting illegal military operations. Massie described the outcome as a “procedural motion to kill the resolution,” noting that the articles could remain in committee indefinitely.
The result hinges on the absence of 11 Democratic lawmakers during the vote. Had these members been present and voted with their colleagues, they would have had the numbers to defeat the procedural move, forcing a full House vote on impeachment as early as that week. The absent Democrats include Nancy Pelosi, Julia Brownley, and Haley Stevens, among others, who cited various reasons such as travel delays, personal emergencies, or health procedures.
The outcome drew sharp criticism from progressive commentators and Democratic politicians. California Congresswoman Sydney Kamlager-Dove argued that there was no excuse for losing the vote due to attendance issues. Pundits also directed frustration at Democratic House leader Hakeem Jeffries, who is set to become the new Speaker of the House in January, accusing him of failing to whip the vote effectively.
Despite the setback, the impeachment process is not over. When the new Congress convenes in January, Democrats will be in a stronger position to revive the effort. Jeffries has indicated that he will consult with members regarding a new bid to impeach Hegseth. However, securing removal from office remains a high bar; while the House votes on articles, the Senate must convict with a two-thirds majority. Given the historical rarity of Senate convictions—only eight federal judges have ever been removed under this process—Democrats would likely need support from at least a dozen Republicans to secure Hegseth’s removal.
President Trump welcomed the House decision, posting on social media that the Democrats’ impeachment effort had “miserably FAILED!”
Health procedures and travel delays? In the middle of an impeachment push? Doubtful.
Trump will enjoy this drama on his social media platform for weeks to come.
Jeffries needs to get better at whipping votes. Waiting for January is just stalling.
Do not forget the Senate hurdle. Impeaching is easy, convicting is nearly impossible without Republicans.
It is wild Massie introduced this. He is truly out of his party lane.
Pelski missing a critical vote really hurts the narrative. They have no alibis for missing this.