The head of the independent commission investigating social care in England has accused successive governments of failing to properly oversee the sector. Baroness Louise Casey described the current state of adult social care as the result of an uncontrolled and unintended development process, contrasting it sharply with the deliberate design of the National Health Service (NHS) established in 1948.
Speaking on Radio 4’s Today programme, Baroness Casey argued that a “postcode lottery” has emerged, where the level of care services available varies significantly depending on a person’s location. She also highlighted financial disparities, noting that individuals who fund their own care through means-testing face fees on average 40% higher than the costs borne by local councils for those entitled to state support.
Baroness Casey criticized the lack of a clear system of stewardship for social care in England, describing the country as an “international outlier” compared to nations like France and Germany. She suggested that the market is dominated by private providers and that the regulator, the Care Quality Commission, has failed to intervene effectively. Additionally, she pointed to findings from a recent pandemic inquiry, which described the care sector as an “afterthought” during the early stages of the crisis, allowing the virus to spread rapidly among vulnerable populations.
The commission’s final recommendations are scheduled for publication next summer. Although the inquiry was established by the Starmer government, current Prime Minister Andy Burnham has identified social care as a key priority. Baroness Casey urged the public and policymakers to work together to create a new framework for care, citing shared national values of decency and duty. Her final report will be presented at a conference of social care leaders later this week.
I am skeptical about the new framework arriving next summer. Promises are made, but has anyone actually fixed this before?
It is shocking that care costs depend on where you live. People should not face such massive fees just for needing help.