BBC broadcaster and director Poppy Jay recently stepped out from behind the camera to experience life as a “tradwife” for a new documentary. Jay, a self-described feminist, stayed for three days with Evangelical Christian couple Molly and Aaron Edwards in Yorkshire, taking on domestic duties traditionally assigned to wives in the traditional wife movement.
The tradwife movement, which advocates for women embracing historical gender roles in the home while deferring to their husbands, has gained significant traction on social media. While proponents view it as a return to wholesome family values, critics argue it reinforces patriarchal inequality and diminishes women’s empowerment. Jay’s participation in the BBC One series Young, British and Tradwife involved helping with cooking, homeschooling, gardening, and tending to chickens over two of the three days.
“I was exhausted,” Jay told BBC News, noting that the relentless pace of the household routine was striking. She observed that Molly Edwards, a mother of seven, manages endless domestic tasks with little personal time. Jay noted parallels between this lifestyle and her own upbringing in a conservative Muslim family, where she experienced arranged marriage and significant domestic responsibilities. However, she found the strict hierarchy within the Edwards home, particularly regarding submission to Aaron, to be a challenging concept.
Aaron Edwards, a theologian who shares anti-feminist views on social media, emphasized the importance of spousal submission. “Molly’s obviously omni-competent and brilliant but submission is still really hard,” he explained. Jay admitted to intellectual sparring with him, particularly regarding his romanticization of past gender roles and his criticism of feminism.
The tradwife phenomenon has been heavily popularized by influencers like Hannah Neeleman, who has over 10 million Instagram followers. However, not all content creators embrace the label; Nara Smith, a popular American influencer who cooks from scratch, has rejected the term, stating her cooking is a hobby rather than a mandate. The trend has also permeated pop culture, with author Caro Claire Burke’s satirical novel Yesteryear selling over 1.4 million copies and securing a Hollywood film deal involving Anne Hathaway.
While some tradwives monetize their lifestyle through brand deals and courses, such as the West Sussex couple Megan and Joseph Landreth-Smith, others like Molly Edwards do not rely on income from social media. A recent report from King’s College London found that 79% of women surveyed were attracted to the relaxed lifestyle imagery presented by tradwives. However, co-author Professor Heejung Chung warned that this appeal could serve as a gateway to extremist ideologies that seek to curtail women’s autonomy, even though most young people surveyed maintained progressive views on gender roles.
The movie deal for that satirical book is a good sign. Maybe society is ready to mock the trend more.
I love that she actually spars intellectually with the husband. Most documentaries just accept everything they are told.
Honestly, the fact that she got exhausted in just two days says everything. It is relentless work disguised as a hobby.
That King’s College report scares me a bit. It’s concerning that 79% of women are drawn to the aesthetic.
Is it possible for a self-described feminist to truly understand a lifestyle that explicitly rejects feminism? I remain skeptical of the whole thing.
I found the connection to her conservative Muslim upbringing really interesting. It shows how domestic expectations cross cultural lines unexpectedly.