Joanne Young and her daughter Alex Young have called on the UK government to amend the law on consent after a trial revealed that a drugged woman was advertised for sex online by her husband, who invited four other men to abuse her.
The incident took place in Swindon, Wiltshire, over a 13-year period in which Philip Young, 50, drugged and abused his wife. Using platforms such as Craigslist, Grindr, and Fab Swingers, Young invited strangers to their home without Joanne Young’s knowledge. On Thursday, four men were found guilty of sexual offences against her, marking the first trial of its kind in England.
The defendants, who were all strangers to one another, claimed they were deceived by Philip Young and believed Joanne Young was consenting to sexual activity. However, prosecutors argued that none of the men sought consent from the victim herself, who was made unconscious. Alex Young, speaking about the case, stated: “It has been 23 years since this was last updated. Society has progressed, crime has progressed. So why hasn’t the law progressed with it?”
The Sexual Offences Act 2003 defines consent as an agreement made by choice, with the freedom and capacity to make that choice. While there is no explicit statutory defense for “third-party consent,” defense lawyers have argued that defendants reasonably believed the victim had consented through her husband. Experts, including criminal barrister Kate Parker, stated that this position is not legally supportable because a person who is unconscious has no capacity to consent, and consent is strictly personal and cannot be given by another individual.
James Foster, a specialist prosecutor from the Crown Prosecution Service, emphasized that Philip Young could not consent on his wife’s behalf. “None of these defendants was entitled to simply assume that she was willing – consent is personal, it cannot be given by somebody else, it cannot simply be assumed,” Foster said.
Former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, Jess Phillips, warned that current laws are insufficient. “These people went on to argue that they reasonably believed that Joanne’s husband had sought her consent and got it. They were found guilty, but it’s whether the law needs to explicitly say, you cannot reasonably believe someone’s given consent unless they have given it,” Phillips told BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour. She added that clearer legislation would prevent victims from enduring such traumatic court proceedings.
Other victims of similar crimes have also spoken out. Laura Bishop, a cyber crime PhD holder from Bristol, waived her anonymity after her ex-husband received a 14-year prison sentence for drugging her and inviting others to abuse her. “It’s something that unfortunately you can never get over… the betrayal, particularly by men, is very difficult to move on from,” Bishop said. She noted that the websites used to advertise the victims remain active and often refuse to provide evidence to police.
Zoe Watts, founder of the global campaign ‘End Eye Check,’ hopes the case sets a legal precedent against drug-facilitated sexual abuse. “I have had women contact me from 25 different countries… It’s a daily process of women either contacting me because they’ve woken up to find their husband having sex with them while they’re asleep,” Watts added.
Debbie Beadle, CEO of the domestic abuse charity Fear Free, noted that six in seven rapes against women are committed by someone they know, creating a significant barrier to reporting. Professor Miranda Horvath, director of the University of Suffolk’s Institute for Social Justice and Crime, called for better implementation of existing legislation, suspect-focused investigations, and holding tech platforms accountable for proliferating such material.
Philip Young pleaded guilty at an earlier hearing to 56 charges, including 14 counts of voyeurism, 11 of rape, and 11 of administering a substance with intent. The other defendants were convicted as follows: Norman Macksoni, 48, and Richard Wilkins, 62, were found guilty of rape; Connor Sanderson-Doyle, 32, was found guilty of sexual assault by touching and penetration; and Mohammed Hassan, 38, was found guilty of sexual assault by touching. A sixth defendant, Dean Hamilton, 47, admitted to one charge of assault by penetration, two of sexual assault, and one of rape in February.
Leave a Reply