Dr. Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, has publicly called for a corporate homicide investigation following allegations of unnecessary deaths among patients at NHS Grampian over a decade.
Speaking at a media conference on Thursday, Dr. Habib stated that he has been raising concerns since 2016, including reporting to government ministers and police, but claims he was ignored. To support his allegations, the whistleblower leaked an unpublished expert review from 2022, which examined 45 patients undergoing liver and pancreatic surgery between 2015 and 2021.
The review concluded that 31 of the patients died, with 19 of those deaths deemed avoidable due to surgical errors or the consequences of intervention. The report criticized decision-making as “overly aggressive” and noted that blood losses in operating theatres were “unacceptably high.”
Dr. Habib formally reported serious concerns regarding dozens of avoidable deaths in 2021 and contacted Police Scotland in February 2024, though no charges have been brought. He described the conduct as “wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient deaths.”
The allegations surfaced a week after Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) published a report identifying major deficiencies in leadership and culture within the NHS Grampian board, noting that a failure to learn from mistakes led to repeated avoidable harm.
Health Secretary Angela Constance responded to the earlier report by insisting that patients are safe and demanding full transparency. A second external report released earlier this year reinforced the findings, recommending that no complex or major hepatopancreatobiliary surgery be performed at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary due to a lack of specialist staff and long-standing issues dating back to 2010.
Dr. Habib said he believes several hundred patients may have been harmed by high complication rates. He noted that the Scottish government previously stated it had no jurisdiction to investigate his whistleblowing claims, and that the Independent Whistleblowing Officer refused to progress his complaints, citing that they were time-barred.
NHS Grampian board management had not commented on the latest public claims as of the time of reporting. In December 2025, NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife Knight responded to Dr. Habib’s correspondence by asking him to allow HIS to complete its enquiries.
The government saying they had no jurisdiction is baffling. Who is actually responsible for oversight?
Unacceptably high blood loss sounds like a complete lack of basic competence in the operating theatre.
Just wait and see if the police actually act. They have already declined to charge previously.
I was a patient there. I am terrified thinking about the surgeries I underwent back then.
Ignoring a whistleblower for seven years is unacceptable. The system failed these families badly.
They recommended stopping complex surgeries there. It feels like patients were used as guinea pigs for years.
Is corporate homicide even a thing in Scotland? I am curious how that legal framework would apply here.
The phrase wicked recklessness really stands out. It suggests a complete breakdown of basic medical ethics and safety protocols.
This is horrifying. Why did it take a decade to acknowledge preventable deaths at such a major hospital?