Costa Rican authorities have arrested a 31-year-old woman and a 34-year-old man on suspicion of murdering American surfer Kurt Van Dyke. The victims’ former girlfriend, identified only by her last name, Arroya, and a man identified as Gutiérrez were detained in a heavily armed nighttime operation last week.
Van Dyke, who was 66 at the time of his death, was found stabbed and strangled at his home in Puerto Viejo de Talamanca earlier in 2025. The victim had resided in Costa Rica since the 1980s and operated a hotel in the town.
Law enforcement officials allege that the two suspects orchestrated a robbery with the specific goal of obtaining PIN codes for bank cards associated with the hotel. Arroya was found alive at the scene and is reported to have sustained no serious injuries during the attack.
Peter Van Dyke, the victim’s brother, described the arrest of his brother’s partner as “shocking” to the family. He noted that it seemed “extremely odd” that Arroya survived the incident unharmed while their brother did not.
“We had our suspicions,” Peter Van Dyke stated. “I can’t say the word ‘happy’ because this is not a happy situation. We’re just satisfied with the outcome so far. I have faith in the Costa Rican law enforcement. It took them nine months, and I totally understand why.”
Kurt Van Dyke, part of a prominent surfing family from Santa Cruz, California, leaves behind three children. His eldest son is expected to travel to Costa Rica for the upcoming murder trial.
His son coming back for the trial shows how close they were. Sad news for the family.
Was he really just a hotel operator? Seems like there would be more security for someone with that status.
Gutierrez and Arroya finally in custody. Good that Costa Rican police actually caught them this time.
The detail about surviving unharmed while he died is truly chilling. Makes you wonder about the whole thing.
Nine months to make arrests feels slow but I get it. Cross-border investigations are incredibly complicated.