Texas Republican Senator John Cornyn has refused to advance the nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Justice Department official, for a federal district court position in the Dallas area. Cornyn withheld the required ‘blue slip’ for Gaiser, effectively stopping the nomination from moving forward in the Senate Judiciary Committee. When speaking with CBS News on Capitol Hill, Cornyn stated that the nomination is no longer viable. He cited Gaiser’s lack of residency in Texas and absence of trial experience as primary reasons for his opposition, noting that the White House attempted to force the nomination without proper consultation.
Gaiser was originally scheduled to appear before the Judiciary Committee for a confirmation hearing on Wednesday, but he was not included among the seven candidates selected to testify. The blue-slip process is a long-standing tradition that requires the two senators representing a nominee’s home state to approve the candidate before they can proceed to a committee hearing. For the Northern District of Texas vacancy, Cornyn and Republican Senator Ted Cruz hold this authority. Although President Trump has pressured Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley to abolish the blue-slip rule, Grassley has maintained the tradition for district court and U.S. attorney nominations.
T. Elliot Gaiser, a native of Ohio who previously served as the state’s solicitor general, joined the Trump administration last year as head of the Office of Legal Counsel at the Justice Department. His only connection to Texas is a one-year clerkship for a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit. In a questionnaire submitted to the committee, Gaiser noted that he was first contacted about the vacancy by Cruz’s staff on November 4, shortly after the midterm elections. He subsequently discussed the potential nomination with Cornyn’s office and was informed by the White House Counsel’s Office that President Trump was considering him for the role. The nomination was formally sent to the Senate on Monday, following Trump’s announcement the previous week.
In the ongoing lame-duck session of Congress, the Judiciary Committee is working quickly to confirm remaining nominees to the federal bench before control of the Senate shifts to the Democratic Party in January. With Democrats expected to hold 56 seats, it is unlikely that many of the president’s picks for federal appeals and district courts will be confirmed. Gaiser has also faced criticism for legal opinions issued during his tenure as associate attorney general, including justifications for military strikes on drug-smuggling vessels and rulings that the Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional and that the president’s private advisers are shielded by executive privilege.
It is hilarious watching the White House panic while Grassley quietly sticks to the rules they swore to keep.
The legal opinions on drug smackers and presidential records were definitely problematic. Good thing he is blocked from this seat.
With Democrats taking the Senate in January, this whole lame-duck rush seems pointless and likely wasted effort.
Blue slips aren’t just rules, they respect local input. This fight only delays confirmation for everyone involved.
I am surprised Gaiser had zero trial experience. How can you judge a district court nominee without that background?
Honestly, forcing an Ohio native onto a Texas bench without local consultation feels completely wrong and ignores the tradition.