Businesses across the UK have reported that rising National Insurance (NI) contributions and minimum wage increases have made it increasingly difficult to hire staff under the age of 25. In response, Alan Milburn’s recent report recommends targeted financial measures to stimulate youth employment, including raising NI thresholds and introducing cash incentives for employers who take on young workers.
The proposals suggest that NI thresholds for workers aged 21 to 24 could be increased from £5,000 to £10,000 over the next five years, with a particular focus on the retail and hospitality sectors. The Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC) stated that this measure hits the “sweet spot” of what firms need to make hiring decisions.
However, the British Chambers of Commerce (BCC) argued that the report does not go far enough, warning that limiting the NI relief to specific sectors could add administrative complexity and block potential career paths for young people. UKHospitality’s chief executive Allen Simpson supported the move, describing it as an immediate boost for job creation.
Additional recommendations include providing a £3,000 payment to employers who hire individuals who have been not in education, employment or training (Neet) for six months. Small businesses with fewer than 50 employees would receive an additional £2,000, and an extra £2,000 would be granted if the hire is a former care leaver or a disabled person. Ally Fir, a bookshop owner in Westbourne, said she would immediately take advantage of such schemes, noting that current employment costs prevent her from expanding her staff despite daily job applications.
Tom Parsons of Aetha design consultancy in Poole recalled the success of the 2020 Kickstart Scheme, which allowed him to place two young people in fully funded jobs, one of whom stayed with the firm for five years. He expressed strong support for similar future incentives.
The report also highlights concerns regarding the government’s plan to replace zero-hours contracts with guaranteed hours contracts. Milburn warned that this change could hinder hiring in a weak youth labor market, a view echoed by the REC, which suggested the issue of Neets provided an opportunity for ministers to reconsider the policy.
To assist recruitment, the report proposes an “opportunity guarantee” that gives young people a legal right to a route into education, training, or work. Dean Greene, a sales director at Williams Environmental, noted that finding staff is difficult due to negative perceptions of certain industries, but believes awareness campaigns could help attract young talent, citing his own career progression from an 18-year-old admin officer to a director over 17 years.
As a shop owner, £3,000 extra helps, but the administrative headache of tracking who is Neet or a care leaver is daunting.
Giving young people a legal right to work? That sounds like a very bold political move for the current government.
The 2020 Kickstart scheme actually worked for my mate’s firm. A permanent version would be a massive win for youth.
Surprised the BCC says it doesn’t go far enough. Most businesses are just struggling to pay rent, let alone pay taxes.
I run a restaurant. The NI cuts help, but the guaranteed hours contract warning is definitely something we all need to worry about.
The care leaver bonus sounds fantastic, but will bureaucracy actually make it easy for small shops to access it?