A major independent review into youth unemployment will recommend that the UK government gradually reduce National Insurance (NI) contributions paid by employers for workers aged between 21 and 24, according to reports. The proposal, developed over the past year by former Labour minister Alan Milburn, aims to incentivize companies to create jobs for young people by lowering labor costs over a five-year period. The report is scheduled for publication on Tuesday.
Milburn’s review addresses the high number of young people not in education, employment, or training (Neets), a statistic of nearly one million individuals aged 16 to 24. While acknowledging that the rise in Neets predates the current government’s decision to increase NI contributions, the report suggests that an immediate across-the-board cut to NI for this age group would cost £5.1 billion, a sum Milburn argues is not a feasible use of public funds given current fiscal conditions. Instead, he proposes doubling the threshold at which businesses begin paying NI for 21- and 24-year-olds from £5,000 to £10,000, with retail and hospitality sectors targeted first as they account for 37% of jobs for young people.
The report will also propose significant changes to benefit structures, recommending that under-25s lose eligibility for the health component of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment (PIP). Milburn argues that supporting skill development is ineffective without available job opportunities, suggesting the government provide a legal guarantee of work, training, or support, with benefits for those who refuse assistance to be cut. This follows Chancellor John Healey’s recent move to slow the equalization of minimum wage bands for younger workers, a decision Milburn supported, citing the high costs imposed on the state by the original Labour manifesto pledge to close wage gaps for 18-to-20-year-olds.
Business owners have expressed mixed reactions to the economic pressures on youth employment. Collette Osborne, a hairdresser in Nottingham, described feeling “suffocated by employment costs,” noting that she has had to halve her workforce to 21 staff and can no longer afford to take on apprentices. “I’m inundated with applications… which is heartbreaking because I can’t take them on,” Osborne said, attributing the issue to high minimum wage requirements and NI costs. She stated that it costs approximately £60,000 to train an apprentice before they are ready for client work.
Political reactions to the review have been divided. Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately criticized the government for taxing businesses while simultaneously subsidizing what she described as “jobs that look like jobs.” She argued that the Labour Party’s regulatory environment makes it harder for businesses to afford young employees, suggesting that employer NI costs should be halved. Conversely, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden announced that the government will extend its subsidised jobs guarantee scheme to 18- to 24-year-olds claiming Universal Credit after 12 months of benefits, aiming to help more than 90,000 young people enter the workforce by March 2029.
Training an apprentice costs so much that I can’t afford to take them on, no matter the incentives.
Why target only 21 to 24 year olds? What about those in their late 20s who are struggling too?
It’s frustrating that the rise in Neets predates the current government, but they still need to fix it.
A job guarantee sounds good on paper, but will there be quality roles or just menial tasks?
I doubt the government will actually implement the benefit cuts, but the NI changes seem likely.
As a small business owner, I agree that the current NI rates are suffocating our ability to hire.
Targeting retail makes sense since so many young people work there, but is it enough for other sectors?
Five years is a long time to wait for changes. Neets need immediate support right now.
Removing PIP for under-25s sounds terrifying. How are they supposed to afford rent or food without that income?
Finally seeing common sense on this. Lowering costs for employers should help them actually hire young people.