Brandi Carlile is currently undertaking a 19-date tour titled “Burn the Setlist!” that is described as a historic first for a major headliner. The concert series is unique because it consists entirely of spontaneous audience requests, abandoning the standard practice of pre-planned setlists. While the concept might seem risky for a performer with a catalog of nearly 100 original songs and numerous covers, Carlile and her bandmates, Phil and Tim Hanseroth, have demonstrated an exceptional ability to recall and perform a wide variety of material on demand.
During a recent performance on November 7 at the Fox Theatre in Oakland, California, Carlile emphasized that the goal was to create a musical experience rather than a trivia quiz. She encouraged fans to request obscure “deep cuts” while also allowing for well-known hits, assuring the audience that no request would be met with judgment. The use of Yondr pouches for mobile phones during the show helped maintain intimacy and prevented the live performance from being immediately uploaded to social media, allowing for unfiltered moments.
The Oakland show featured 22 songs, including a mix of rowdy older tracks like “Raising Hell” and poignant personal songs such as “The Mother.” Carlile shared a detailed story about writing “The Mother,” a song that explores gay motherhood, and how its message proved universal to a diverse audience. The tour also highlights real-time problem-solving, such as when the trio adapted a cover of Alanis Morissette’s “Uninvited” to a guitar and bass arrangement after realizing they could not replicate the original string section setup.
It sounds risky, but honestly, who wants a generic pop set? This feels much more personal.
Brilliant concept. The story about adapting the Alanis cover shows real musicianship. I’m in.
Wouldn’t they run out of time? How do they handle requests they absolutely cannot play?
I loved the phone pouch idea. It makes the concert feel like a genuine shared memory instead of just content.