Legal representatives for the heirs of the Fischer family have challenged the upcoming auction of a Vincent van Gogh painting at Sotheby’s, alleging the artwork was sold under duress during the rise of the Nazi regime in Germany. The painting, titled *Châtaigniers en fleurs* (Blossoming Chestnut Trees), is scheduled to go to auction in New York this Wednesday with a pre-sale estimate of $180 million (£136 million).
Sotheby’s responded to the claims by stating that while it takes provenance and restitution matters seriously, its extensive research into the ownership history of the piece has not established that the sale was coerced. The auction house confirmed it is in dialogue with the Fischer heirs and is committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution regarding the painting’s complex history.
According to the heirs’ legal counsel, the painting was sold in Amsterdam prior to World War II because Samuel Fischer, a renowned German publisher who acquired the work in 1909, suffered significant financial losses due to Nazi policies affecting his publishing company. The lawyer reportedly communicated this assessment to Sotheby’s in a recent letter.
The artwork is being offered as part of the Blaquier-Arrieta Collection. Sotheby’s has detailed the provenance of the oil painting on its website, noting it changed hands multiple times between 1890 and its current auction. After Samuel Fischer’s death in 1934, the painting was passed down in his family. It was deposited with art dealer Paul Cassirer in Amsterdam in 1932 or 1933, and subsequently transferred to Henriette and Marcel Kapferer in Paris in 1936 before passing through four additional owners.
The BBC has reached out to the lawyer representing the Fischer heirs for further comment on the dispute.
I hope the heirs win. Restitution is just about right, even if the legal proofs are messy.
Paul Cassirer’s involvement makes this complicated. He was a prominent dealer, but also a target. Tricky history.
They will probably delay the auction by months. Bidders should have their money ready for a long wait.
Samuel Fischer was a huge figure. It hurts to see his legacy fought over in a courtroom like this.
Sotheby’s saying they ‘seek resolution’ usually means they want to settle quietly to avoid bad press.
If it was sold in Amsterdam before the war, does that even count as Nazi-era duress? I need the timeline details.
Eighty dollars for a Van Gogh? The market is completely detached from reality right now, regardless of ownership disputes.
The financial pressure on publishers back then was intense, so duress claims are plausible. Sotheby’s needs to prove otherwise.