Former Labour minister Alan Milburn has called for a legal guarantee that young people will have access to a job, training, or employment support, warning that those who refuse this aid could face sanctions on their welfare payments.
Speaking ahead of the publication of his major review on Tuesday, Milburn argued that the UK government needs to drastically shift its spending priorities. He noted that current spending on benefits for young people is approximately 25 times higher than funding for employment support, a ratio he believes should be reduced to two-to-one.
Milburn proposed an “opportunity guarantee” that would place a permanent legal duty on the state to ensure young people have a clear pathway into employment. He compared this concept to existing legal obligations for local councils to house homeless individuals or care for children in the system. The former MP stated that the current system, which guarantees benefits rather than prospects, is insufficient for a functioning society.
The review highlights that the government currently spends £22 billion annually supporting young people who are economically inactive. Milburn suggested that under-25s should no longer be eligible for certain health-related benefits, such as the personal independence payment and the health element of Universal Credit, to encourage transition into the workforce.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has described the forthcoming report as a “watershed moment” for how the UK supports young people. While Burnham emphasized that the reforms would involve “spending differently” rather than increasing the overall budget, he stopped short of guaranteeing that all recommendations would be adopted, noting that the government’s full response will be provided next week.
The proposal has drawn mixed reactions from the political opposition. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch suggested the schemes would ultimately fail, while Reform UK’s economy spokesperson Robert Jenrick criticized the review as pointless without immediate government action. Meanwhile, the Liberal Democrats have advocated for a 100-hour work experience guarantee, and the Green Party has warned against demonizing disabled and young people, urging a focus on structural inequalities.
According to recent data from the Office for National Statistics, almost one million young people in the UK are currently not in education, employment, or training.
Stop demonizing young people. Many are stuck in bad jobs or unpaid internships right now.
If you refuse training, you lose benefits? That sounds like coercion rather than support.
The Lib Dem idea of guaranteed work experience might be more practical than a strict legal right.
Burnham calling it a watershed moment is classic politician spin. Let us see the actual details.
Million young people out of education and work is a huge problem. This is overdue.
Cutting health benefits for young people seems like a bad idea. Health and work are connected.
I remember similar schemes in the 90s. Did that ever actually work for anyone long term?
Sanctioning benefits feels harsh. What about those with genuine mental health issues who genuinely cannot work?
The 25-to-1 spending ratio is actually shocking. We need to shift that budget to training, not just handouts.