Following the recent election, election officials and civil rights attorneys in California are bracing for continued federal efforts to identify noncitizens on state voter rolls, even after the Trump administration faced significant legal obstacles. James Williams, the county executive for Santa Clara County, stated that the administration’s drive to find voter fraud is expected to persist regardless of the election outcome.
In the weeks leading up to Election Day, the Department of Justice (DOJ) escalated its pressure on election officials, including the issuance of criminal charges against dozens of individuals accused of voting without citizenship. However, legal experts note that noncitizen voting is exceptionally rare, and the administration has previously promoted inflated figures regarding the number of noncitizens on voter rolls. In mid-October, federal officials alleged that 20,000 likely noncitizens were on California’s rolls, prompting a lawsuit to force officials not to count unverified ballots. Federal courts rejected these requests, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to intervene.
Although the DOJ dropped its lawsuit last week, it has not rescinded grand jury subpoenas sent to various California counties, including Los Angeles, Santa Clara, and Sonoma. These subpoenas request records related to how local officials responded to federal demands. U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche affirmed at a press conference that the department will continue to investigate election integrity cases criminally and civilly.
Legal analysts point out that recent court rulings have created substantial hurdles for federal intervention. A judge in Washington, D.C., ruled that the DOJ and the Department of Homeland Security lack statutory authority to distribute lists of purported noncitizens to election officials, citing violations of the Privacy Act. Another order vacated the DOJ’s project to request unredacted voter rolls from states for comparison with federal databases. Both rulings are expected to be appealed by the federal government.
Local prosecutors, such as San Luis Obispo District Attorney Dan Dow, are continuing their investigations into federally flagged registrations. While Dow has charged one individual, experts like Loyola Law School professor Justin Levitt anticipate only a small number of actual noncitizen voting cases, consistent with historical data. Meanwhile, the credibility of the federal lists remains under scrutiny. A recent analysis by UCLA’s Voting Rights Project found that 42% of the 20,000 names on the DOJ’s list did not appear on California’s current voter roll, and many listed individuals were naturalized citizens. County officials have also reported widespread duplicates and inaccuracies, including impossible birth dates.
The federal government has not provided a complete list of U.S. citizens, leading to false matches in its data. With Democrats now controlling Congress, lawmakers may pursue hearings to examine whether federal officials violated the Privacy Act by using voter roll data without required public notice procedures.
Subpoenaing county offices for how they handled requests? That is a clever way to keep the pressure on without actually proving fraud.
As a naturalized citizen, it is stressful to see my name potentially flagged by mistake. The system needs better verification processes.
They keep calling it voter integrity, but honestly, it looks more like political theater to us. The actual fraud cases are practically non-existent.
Do you think they will finally drop these charges when Democrats take over Congress, or will this turn into a years-long legal battle?
The 42% error rate on that list is honestly embarrassing. How do you even defend accuracy when nearly half the names don’t even exist?
I am genuinely surprised that subpoenas are still active after those major court losses for the administration. This feels like a lot of wasted effort.