Strategists at Citigroup argue that the normalization of corporate profit surprises during the third-quarter earnings season is a sign of a healthier stock market. With more than 88% of S&P 500 companies having released their results, 84% reported earnings per share that exceeded analyst consensus, a figure higher than the five-year average of 78%, according to data from FactSet.
However, the magnitude of these outperformance events has declined significantly. On average, firms that posted beats reported earnings just 2.6% above estimates, well below the five-year average of 7.5% and far lower than the roughly 23% average seen last year. Scott Chronert and Patrick Galvin, the Citi strategists, noted in a report published Thursday that this shift reflects a ‘new normal’ where the exceptionally strong surprise dynamics of the previous year are fading, particularly in the artificial intelligence sector which is now following a more idiosyncratic path.
While the breadth of sectors posting better-than-expected results was encouraging, the modest size of the beats led to a muted reaction in stock prices. Semiconductors recorded some of the more positive surprises, but energy was the primary driver of sector performance after oil companies posted strong results amid a spike in crude prices linked to the conflict in Iran.
The Citi team viewed the stability in earnings as a positive development but cautioned that macroeconomic or political tailwinds will be necessary next year to encourage analysts to raise corporate earnings targets. A primary risk identified is the escalating cost of the AI infrastructure buildout. The strategists warned that hyperscaler cash balances are decreasing, debt issuance is rising rapidly, and the drag from incremental interest expense is growing. Consequently, they noted that earnings estimates face downside risk if financing costs and equity dilution exceed consensus expectations.
This concern has been heightened by recent midterm elections in which Democrats secured control of both the Senate and the House of Representatives, introducing uncertainty regarding data center financing. Although Wall Street expects the growth in AI capital expenditure to peak in the near term, which has weighed on related stocks, Citi analysts argue that the long-term persistence of AI spending is more significant than short-term earnings beats. They concluded that the overall earnings setup remains solid and suggested that recent stock market pullbacks present an opportunistic buying opportunity for investors.
2.6 percent beats versus 23 percent last year. It makes sense that stock reactions have been so muted.
Buying the dip now? I hope they are right, but those financing risks feel like a ticking time bomb.
Energy driving performance? I didn’t think crude prices would matter this much during an AI boom.
So basically, the crazy spikes are over? That sounds like a relief for anyone managing risk.
The AI debt issue worries me. Rising interest costs might crush those profit margins faster than we expect.
Wait, Democrats took both chambers? That political shift could completely change the funding landscape for data centers.
Small surprises are better than big shocks. Consistency really does build a more stable foundation for the market.