The documentary ‘You Can See Everything,’ directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, is emerging as a contender to make Academy Awards history by becoming the first nonfiction film to receive a Best Picture nomination. The film, produced by A24, premiered at the Telluride Film Festival in September and generated nearly $80 million in domestic box office revenue by its fourth weekend of release on October 16.
Despite its commercial success and a sweep of the Critics Choice Documentary Awards, the film’s Oscar campaign has taken a strategic turn. A24 initially listed the movie in 11 categories, including Best Picture, Director, Supporting Actress, and Documentary Feature, as well as several craft categories such as production design, cinematography, and sound. However, an updated awards site subsequently removed the film from the artisan races for production design, costume design, makeup and hairstyling, and sound. This trimming of the campaign aligns with a broader trend in which nonfiction films primarily break through in music or specific craft categories rather than mainstream narrative races.
Historically, documentaries have faced significant barriers at the Academy Awards. Across 98 ceremonies, nonfiction films have earned only 33 nominations in categories outside of Documentary Feature, with just three wins. No documentary has ever been nominated for Best Picture or Best Director. The most recent documentary to win an Oscar outside its own category was ‘An Inconvenient Truth’ (2006), which took home the award for Best Original Song.
The path to crossover recognition for documentaries has often run through the Original Song category, where 12 films have been nominated. Additionally, international feature film submissions have provided another avenue, with titles like ‘Honeyland’ (2019), ‘Collective’ (2020), and ‘Flee’ (2021) receiving simultaneous nominations in Documentary and International Feature categories, though none secured wins in all respective races.
For ‘You Can See Everything,’ the Best Picture race is decided by the full voting membership of more than 10,000 industry professionals, rather than the smaller Documentary Branch. This structure presents both an opportunity and a risk; while the film may find support among general voters despite skepticism from the documentary branch, it faces the possibility of a notable snub in the Documentary Feature category. Variety’s current Oscar predictions suggest the film may earn three nominations: Best Picture, Supporting Actress for Kate McKinnon’s co-star (though the text specifies ‘Seyfried’ likely referring to the actress involved, contextually Kate McKinnon or the specific cast member, but strictly following the text ‘Seyfried’ is mentioned as eligible for acting), and Film Editing, while potentially missing the Documentary Feature nomination entirely.
The full voter membership deciding this is wild. The Documentary Branch could easily snub them in return.
Skeptical it will happen. The documentary branch usually ignores these crossover attempts completely, in my experience.
Finally! It is past time for a documentary to break into the mainstream Best Picture conversation.
Does trimming craft categories actually help the overall pitch, or is it just confusing voters right now?
Nathan Fielder doing this? I am genuinely surprised. I did not expect A24 to push for Best Picture.