Brazil’s Superior Electoral Court (TSE) has ordered Meta, the parent company of Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, to pay a fine of 7.5 million reais (approximately $1.34 million or €1.22 million) for failing to fully comply with judicial directives issued during the recent presidential election.
The unanimous ruling on Tuesday cited Meta’s missed deadlines and lack of transparency in its handling of the court’s requests. However, the court explicitly stated that there is currently no evidence suggesting that the tech giant deliberately acted to influence the outcome of the race.
The complaint was filed by the coalition of President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva ahead of the October 25 runoff vote. Accusations included “algorithmic manipulation” that allegedly favored President Lula’s far-right rival, Flavio Bolsonaro. While Meta told the court last month that it had implemented measures to ensure equal treatment for both campaigns, the TSE found that the company’s overall handling of the orders—including delays and incomplete disclosures—warranted the financial penalty.
Marco Aurelio Bellizze, the reporting judge on the case, noted that proving intentional interference would require robust evidence obtained through appropriate legal proceedings. “That conclusion would require robust evidence, to be produced through the appropriate legal proceedings,” he wrote in the ruling.
Meta strongly disputed the decision in a statement released on Wednesday. “We will continue to present the facts and defend ourselves against false allegations in the ongoing legal proceedings,” the company said.
Following his victory in the runoff, where he secured 51.7% of the vote compared to Bolsonaro’s 48.2%, President Lula emphasized the need for stronger regulation of big tech platforms. “We had to overcome foreign interference in the election, coming from outside through digital platforms that we will have to regulate,” Lula said in his victory speech.
Honestly, missing deadlines sounds like basic negligence, which makes the fine seem reasonable, not excessive.
I wonder if other countries are watching this case closely to see if it sets a legal precedent.
Meta denying the allegations is their standard playbook now. I am not surprised by their response.
Lula needs to start regulating other foreign platforms too if he is serious about digital sovereignty.
Does this actually change how algorithms work here, or is it just a paper victory for the court?
Seven and a half million reais feels like a minor slap on the wrist for a company this big.
It is interesting that the court found no evidence of deliberate bias, just procedural failures.